when you write this exactly what do you mean... are you comparing just Kontakt library to Sampletank library... or that Sampletank is light on the CPU compared to Kontakt and some of their libraries i.e. Electri6ty... you are not a fan of the scripting/round robin/etc that Kontakt have... and least but not least the libraries available for Kontakt is out of this world... have you ever demoed Heavyocity stuff? without any flames i would like to understand your comparison of Sampletank and Kontakt... personally... i would put Kontakt in the same class as
Steinberg Halion 5 and Sampletank in the same class as Hypersonic... Hypersonic does not stream from disk... just like Sampletank... Hypersonic has a small footprint just like Sampletank i.e. easy on the CPU... there is no scriping/round robin/etc in Hypersonic... same as Sampletank... i have just updated/upgraded to Halion Sonic 2 and i see Sampletank 3 being in competition with Halion Sonic 2 and not Kontakt or Halion 5...
i guess individuals could look at products differently... but just by the libraries available for Kontakt alone in my opinion there is no comparison... i have owned both Kontakt and Sampletank since version 1... i have seen little to no growth with Sampletank i.e. sound libraries/features and libraries for Kontakt come out about everyday...
i just think Sampletank has to caught up to
Halion Sonic 2 before their is a comparison with Kontakt...
no flames just a discussion!!!
HALion Sonic 2 - Getting started - YouTube
in closing... having CPU power and ram is key to using Kontakt... if an individual cant run Studio Drummer, Scarbee MM-BASS, The Giant,
Scarbee Mark I, Vintage Organ and Session Horn/Mojo Horns at the same time i.e. the instruments used in a traditional funk band (i cant run the above on my lappy but no problems with my desktop) then i could see Sampletank being useful to fill the gaps...
right or wrong these are my views... could you elaborate on your views... again... no flames just conversation/discussion on the subject matter!!!