L. A. Stone said:
I was focusing in on the usual suspects that people actually use or might consider using/buying LOL.
But based on these products, saying that "software modules are losing ground" when beginning to compare them to the advanced performance capabilities of hardware units is actually quite misleading. It sounded like this was a common problem in software, when in reality there are heaps of exquisitly performance-responsive sounds in software alone. Did you give a listen to the other products I linked to, by the way?
L. A. Stone said:
These packages pretend to be high quality but are far from what you find in GigaStudio and other very, very expensive packages, or Motif, Fantoms, and Tritons and so on.
Gigastudio Ensemble, capable of 160 voices polyphony, costs around 240 euros. It has full ReWire support and functions merrily in a 2.5 GHz Pentium 4 machine which is otherwise on par with modern audio production. Trust me, most of the
actual audio systems I've seen people describe here (with separate hard drives for audio use and everything) are fully capable of running it. As for its sounds, there is a wide range of prices, going up to the ridiculous super-pro prices, yes. Still, unlike when paying a big amount of money for a single package with heaps of different factory sounds, you can decide to invest more money in the specific sounds you want to be top-notch -- and they really will be.
I'm not trying to advocate the use of any one product, but only stating that the idea of software sounding generally inferior is starting to get really dated.
L. A. Stone said:
Just trying to keep it realistic but sure I've know about packages like GigaStudio for years. I've also read about the setups required to effectively run such setups in articles about some of the people/professionals who actually use them. Not the kind of setups you will find in any of our bedrooms.
Funny, I've seen so many setups over here meeting those requirements that it would be hard to count them. It's me who's trying to keep it realistic

... A hardware workstation has a lot of uses, but it doesn't justify describing and treating software with dated impressions.
skillz said:
Thats a good point, cause we cant always afford to upgrade on ram, and hardrive space, whenever Gigastudio decides to release another 5 DVD's full of realistic sounds and software.
The people at Tascam aren't exactly going to come over and force you to cram 5 DVDs full of unwanted sounds into your computer any more than a hardware manufacturer is twisting your arm to get you to install an unneeded expansion for your chosen device
But, to reiterate, this isn't specifically about Gigastudio, it's about the quality of software solutions moving way upwards during the last couple of years -- and continuing to go up.