I don't think "Eatin" is questionable. Yes you should enjoy making the music. I totally agree and to add to that you shouldn't have to try to make some shit that's not you and STILL be able to be successful. That was my point. And Tech was my example, he's not chasing no club hit and he's surviving in the music market. The op says if hip hop is to survive in the the music market it should be more clubby...Why should I believe that when somebody like Tech is doing his thing and handling his business?
What I was saying(sorry if it sounded like I was disagreeing with your entire post)is that Tech wasn't a mastermind or genius with some drawn out plan knowing the results because of charts or spreadsheets, he was a guy who made music he liked and found a lane. It took him years of doing music before finding his audience on a level where most artists fade away from. He had label situation after label situation, flopped albums, indie albums features that were supposed to make his career that didn't, and somewhere within all that, made it big in a demographic he didn't realize f**ked with him until late in the game. Nelly's first debut on a commercial scale was a club hit and he was INSTANTLY rich.
No 2 stories are the same. Once upon a time money was so easy in music that the idiot suits in the offices could "invent" the next music star. Rules have changed now, and when the most many artists who "make it" these days get is 1 big song before dwindling away, more than ever you should focus on making what you feel is quality music.
Whether that's club, street, whatever. But you can't relate Tech to "hip hop" when he's bumping behind rock music. As dope of an MC as he is, I take nothing from him, but, if anything, Tech lets us know that if you make rap that plays well with rock music you'll be okay...that's just as "true" as the OP's statement. Worked for B.o.B. with airplanes also, but that makes it no more of a "look at this guy" template than club hits.
Any type of music has the ability to ascend or flop unpredictably more than ever these days. So you should stick to what you're great at doing and hope for the best. That's all I was saying, just feel Tech is no more of an example of a guy doing something right than some rapper successful at club music right now. WTF does Aloe Blacc do? Cause he's huge right now, oh, he does him. Same for Bruno Mars. Lil Jon's doing club music...but wait, it sounds like it coulda gone on one of his albums from a decade ago. Same for Juicy J. Drake? No clue what that is...Emo-rap? But it works for him.
Sorry for the essay trying to explain, just wanted to make sure I got my point across. To say "look at Tech N9ne" is no better than referencing 20 guys with recent club hits for the opposing argument. Once upon a time guys like Tech and Yuk should have been looked at and we may not have arrived at this industry of guys waiting around for a suit to cut them a check. But in 2014, no one's success is guaranteed more than another 15 minutes. Consumers have short attention spans these days.