Butter rugs are not mandatory, although very helpful. These slip mats allow for maximum control of your record, and ultimate slippage. If you do not have a very good needle, do not bother with Butter Rugs, because as soon as you begin to do massive scratches, such as a high paced scribble, the needle will jump directly off. I use my butter rug slippery side down, because I prefer my slipmat to grasp along the record, but you could experient with the other side up. If you like making shortcuts, and do not like to see money comming out of your pocket(LIKE ME!), use a piece of plastic or the wax paper that holds the record, and shape it to the bottom of your slipmat, this way, it will work close enough to a butter rug. But! this is only temporary and after the fifth time, you might as well buy the butter rug....there are no shortcuts for the needle, whichever way you chose (Spherical stylus or Elliptical Stylus) your bound to be screwed in the long run, but I prefer Spherical although it wears out your record alot faster. The upside of the Spherical is that when you do heavy scratching, it won't jump off or skip around the record. I hope this was helpful. Dj Era