kanye West doesnt make his own beats

  • Thread starter Thread starter JAMESRRTT
  • Start date Start date
So this is an interesting subject and I have a related question for yall:

What's the line between a session musician (or contributing musician) and a co-producer??? Is is simply related to the contractual agreement between the parties?

So, for example, if I hire a bassist in a "work for hire" agreement (that we agree to in advance) to write and record a bassline for me, he is a contributing musician, but if we don't agree to WFH in advance, since he composed the bassline, he is considered a co-producer? Yes?

No. He is the person that created and played the bassline of that song. Songwriter credits. O.K......bass player has the "whole concept" of a song, and a producer uses that song but instead of using the bass players "drums and electric guitar licks in his version" he hires a drummer to play a new creation of his drums, and a guitar player to play those licks correctly using maybe some delay on it or whatever. Bassplayer gets co-producer credit then.....his idea perfected by "the producer".

Or lets go deeper. It's his bassline before a song was thought of....he is the owner of the (bassline). He is allowing you to use it (to create another song). Of course it must be some kind of agreement for what the bassplayer would want for using his bassline. Money up front, to be a co - producer of the song ect.
 
Last edited:
Although I didn't bother reading most of this thread the answer is simple. In Hip Hop for some reason everybody expects the producer of a track to be the beatmaker.

A record producer is an individual working within the music industry, whose job is to oversee and manage the recording (i.e. "production") of an artist's music. A producer has many roles that may include, but are not limited to, gathering ideas for the project, selecting songs and/or musicians, coaching the artist and musicians in the studio, controlling the recording sessions, and supervising the entire process through mixing and mastering. Producers also often take on a wider entrepreneurial role, with responsibility for the budget, schedules, and negotiations.
Today, the recording industry has two kinds of producers: executive producer and music producer; they have different roles. While an executive producer oversees a project's finances, a music producer oversees the creation of the music.
A music producer can, in some cases, be compared to a film director, with noted practitioner Phil Ek himself describing his role as "the person who creatively guides or directs the process of making a record, like a director would a movie. The engineer would be more the cameraman of the movie."[1] The music producer's job is to create, shape, and mold a piece of music. The scope of responsibility may be one or two songs or an artist's entire album – in which case the producer will typically develop an overall vision for the album and how the various songs may interrelate.
 
Beatmakers were really DJ's who looped records.......then the drum machine, then the sampler, then the chopping of drum hits from records, then saying forget the records because it cuts into my moneys man, which is what we see today...people playing with synth sounds and whatever creating there own music as "songwriters" who need someone to partner with them on the "songwriting". So now the real question is who is the (producer and co producer) when someone "buys" an exclusive right to "use" it? It's not titled beat #2934 no more when the rapper records and bounce it down.....and puts the song on itunes and you don't even know. But he puts your name as the producer because you made the beat.....and/or the agreement states that you must be given credit as the producer. He don't have to if you don't tell him to...because you are not the producer of the song he made, you are the producer of beat #2934. Ain't no co--->lab, he went searching for beats and bumped into yours and liked it, so he bought it and made a song. When using these beat sites you got to really understand the "sites" rules. They are selling beats under their rules, not yours.
 
taken from an interview with ken Lewis

DX: What are some pros and cons of working with 'Ye? What’s the most fun to do with him, and what’s the worst to deal with?

Ken Lewis: Usually, I don’t work in the same room with him. He’ll call me up, ask me what he needs, and let me do my work at my studio. Most of what I do for Kanye involves me creating music in one way or another, and all of my tools to create music the best way are at my own studio.

There have been occasions…one time, he called me before the 2005 Grammy Awards. He asks me, “Ken, what are you doing today?” I say, “Whatever you want me to be doing.” [Laughs] That’s pretty much my stock answer whenever he calls. He says, “Come to New York. I need you to make an interlude for my Grammy performance, live.“ I’m like, “Okay.” So I literally brought my entire studio to Sony Music Studios, I think the only thing I used at Sony was their chair. Kanye comes in, and he’s like, “After 'Jesus Walks,' it’s going to be me up in silhouette, and then I want this big, cinematic, sweeping orchestral thing. Then there’s going to go into a car crash, I’m going to die, and the angels are going to take me away into a gospel song. I need you to do the big, sweeping orchestral thing.” I’m like, “Sure, I can do that, no problem.” He doesn’t say, “Do you know how to make the big, sweeping orchestral thing?” He just says, “This is what you’re doing.” This is Kanye, I’ll find a way to do this on an amazing level. He hums me a basic melody, and that’s it. It was a 10-minute meeting, he comes in, gives me this animated rundown of what he wants, hums a basic melody, and says, “Go.” He never came back to the studio. Fourteen hours later, I was finished creating the orchestral interlude, and a week later, I was sitting at the Staples Center on the floor at the Grammy Awards, watching Kanye perform “Jesus Walks” into my interlude.

You never know what a day is going to be like with Kanye. I think on of the craziest things about what I do with him and for him, is it’s never the same thing. Sometimes I’ll do sample recreations for him, because I’m pretty much the go-to guy for that—I hate doing them, but I’m good at them. It’s tedious, grueling work, but somebody’s got to do it, and I seem to be the best. I did the horn arrangements on “All Of The Lights”
play_button_article_blk.gif
. Again, he gives me this really basic melody, he calls me up and he’s like, “Ken, I need you to do a horn section on this. Here’s the melody, I just need you to blow it up into this big,” whatever he was telling me he wanted it to sound like. That was extent of the conversation: five minutes. I went, brought in my horn section, did the whole thing here, sent it back to him and he loved it. That’s what made the record. But he didn’t ask me before he hired me, “Hey, do you know how to arrange horns?” [Laughs] You might think that would be the first question, but he never asks me. I guess I’ve come through for him in so many crazy roles over the past few years, he pretty much figures, “Ken will figure out how to do it, so we’ll send it to him.” It’s a pretty good position to be in. I seem to be not be one of his inner circle guys, but I work on every one of his albums, and he knows whatever he asks me to do, I’ll get it done in a great way—I hope.


from gs

As far as last minute Kanye requests, well, it would take an artist of almost equal caliber on my plate on a tight deadline for me to not drop everything else i'm doing when Kanye calls with a tight deadline. I've been working with him since long before the College Dropout and if he needs me, he's got me. If i lose another client over it, well, you know what, Kanye's been a great client for like 9 years now, I'll survive. And of course i would do everything in my power imaginable to not piss off any other clients ever, but if it came down to a choice, welllllll
winknudge.gif


As far as horn players not being available, thats exactly what happened for "New Day". It was a super last minute call. all my first call horn guys were unavailable, but they are all super pro's and they recommended other excellent players for me who showed up on a moments notice.

Someone asked if i write horn charges with a pen, or just musically, or ??? With "New Day" the turn around time for it was so short, i got the call at 1pm and had to deliver a finished section to the Mercer by 7pm. I wrote the horn parts mostly in my head in the car on the way to the studio in Manhattan with the song on loop. When i got to the studio, i just vibed with the horn players and worked them out, changed up a few things, tried a couple other ideas on the fly, it all worked out and i was at the Mercer by about 7:15pm with finished, comp'd, blended mixed horn section. It wasnt a hugely difficult part, and Kanye set out the basic melody for me, so i just had to arrange and record it for a section. Not easy but not overly challenging for me. All Of The Lights was MUCH more work.

you also gotta keep in mind that when you are dealing with great session players, they pick up on things really quickly, they mostly play really well in tune with feel. things go fast if i have my ish together.
 
Last edited:
i never really thought he did all that stuff by himself. i mean c'mon, after college dropout, the music got way bigger in terms of musical compositions. but thats doesn't make him any less of a producer, did you see how many people participated in stevie wonder's songs in the key of life?........
yeah but stevie's blind so he would need help, lol jk
 
It takes a musical mind to do what Stevie or Quincy does. Kanye IMO comes up with great ideas in his mind....can he go to all of these different musicians, hum a full string section (not a loop) but how he wants it done throughout the song? And the same with the drums, and the same with bass, and the same with the paino? Not just one song, but a multitude of songs? Now that right there is the advantage of knowing how to write sheet music and have the entire tune in your head without having an instrument around you. People today get too much credit for these loops they create (not dissing just saying). A man makes a beat and full song complete in an hour......and brags about it......but hasn't made anything close to the level of the stuff from even a decade before he made it. Not trying to jump off topic but..

I can live with this timeless shit right here til I die. IDGAF who made the beat, wrote the lyric, I'm glad it all came out like it did.

Make some shit like this in an hour. This IMO is classic among all the classics. And it can be done today! The fuuck wrong people! Now I'm all pissed and shit.
 
I can't wrap my head around the idea that these artists would be content in just rapping or singing when you have these huge producers fully capable of teaching and/or serving as a great example of the right way to make songs/beats. I would love to see a professional, at work rapper, engineer, or producer.
 
Last edited:
No one mentioned it but some rappers don't even write their own raps...

Some singers don't even write their own songs...

Some boxers don't even train themselves...

The world is about to end.
 
Lol @ a member of future producers not understanding what a producer is.
There are dope producers in the industry who never "hands on" touched a single keyboard or mpc.

this sites name should be futurecomposers.com
i'd honestly be fine with that title.
 
No one mentioned it but some rappers don't even write their own raps...

Some singers don't even write their own songs...

Some boxers don't even train themselves...

The world is about to end.

Hahah what happened to your account?
 
Its ironic how his beats were better when he did do them himself. I really liked the beats he made for other rappers before he switched to rapping. Even Just Blaze hires keyboardists and other musicians to replay samples. It's all about utilizing your available resources at that given time. Once you become famous, you have access to other musicians and aspiring producers.
 
Let's remember that a producer in anything else like tv or movies isn't actually doing much besides giving out directions and spearheading the projects. Kanye can still be a producer if he told everyone what to play and not play a thing himself.
 
Kanye is a real producer.

In any other genre "producing" doesn't mean making the beat.

To be a producer is to deliver a RECORD in it's entirety.

Kanye may not program the beats but he has the vision behind them, and that's all that matters.
 
This may sound like a dumb question. I got it all confused, but is a Record Producer and a Music Producer 2 diffrent things?
 
Last edited:
I think that its a natural progression to work with other producers to expand your sound. Kanye has been making beats for so long that eventually the creativity runs out. It helps to be influenced by other producers in the room, to vibe off each other. I don't see a problem with that.
 
If you read up on kanye enuff you'd know he gets a 'little' out side help.. He does make his own beats though dumbass for instance i read an article talkin bout his album and he'll be like oh dese drums don't sound good to me etc etc ima shoot it over to dre and have him mix it for me cuz he's good at that... Dre will tweak it them next thing you know it says 'co-produced by dre' etc... He makes his own joints for the most part but he might get an outside mixer or a lil help from time to time he's still all original
 
Back
Top