I wouldnt know honestly as I've nevr compared the two, I just know I liked the Rokit 5's alot, even compared to other monitors I A/B'd them against which were double their price. They definetly held their own. They also have the 8's now which are pretty inexpensive. Never heard them but I would assume they sound pretty nice as well. I can understand your concern for wanting a bigger size over 5"...I use some right now and wish I had some 6's or 8" which would register more in the low end since I do mainly hip-hop and electronic, but I would take a good sound, clarity and flat accuracy in a smaller speaker anyday over a bigger, louder and bassier, sloppier set which are of a ****tier build and quality, and might not be as flat and accurate. Just something to consider. It might be worth it to you to wait a month or two and save more cash to get what you really want the first time. good luck-
555