i had a small mackie and it was very very clean , so i was pleased about that. not much character tho....
i had to buy a behringer coz i got a 48 channel desk very very cheap, but i agree that they are pretty pants.
the nicest are the big boys like neve or cadac but thats a second mortgage........
if you only need lots of inputs to sub down and dont need the full functions on each channel strip, then i reckon the mackie sr 24 or 32 would do. (small, clean).
however, if you're using it for multitrack recording and need the desk eq/auxes etc. then maybe a s/h DDA or even yamaha make some pretty acceptable desks which come in at good prices .
soundcraft and soundtracs a;so do some good desks at similar domestic prices.
soundtracs recently scored a huge hit with their digital desks, the virtua, DPC II/3/4 (we have 7 of then here, and they are constantly improving .) i would imagine that their analogue desks would have to have undergone similar improvements to
keep the company happy?
if i were buying a desk , i would think that they are a good alternative. if you get a chance to play with one, let me know?
regards
JB