Sound more important than melody?

gamblerrrr

New member
Hi recently more I am focused at finding great sounds more I am experiencing how hard it actally is.I have no idea how to do it or where to get those great profesional sounding presets..There is a lot of possibilities where to buy some but honestly I am not happy with those sounds ,probably because I have no idea how to layer leads,bass or whatever..I believe that sound is more important than melodies because if you watch some youtube remakes you can hear that every great song is most of the time killed just by wrong sound design..All those "greatest" melodies sound as cheap as the actuall cheap sounds.So its possible to learn sound designing?Are all those famous producers such a good sound designers or they only do a melody and they have a team of specialist for sound designing?I like a pop songs from Avicii,Calvin Harris and I like those great, clear and simple sounds..I have no idea how to achieve similar results?I find a lot of tutorials but they sound not even close to avicii or Calvin Harris original tracks:(
 
Timbre is important in conveying the message, but "sounds" in the generic sense you are thinking of---hellllllll no. Listen to some jazz or some great soul singers and musicians then tell me "sounds" are more important than melody.

 
I recommend you to watch some remakes videos on youtube,compare them to original songs and you will see how important sound or timbre is.We are talking about same thing I guess..Also singers voice matter a lot.Because there is big difference if the same melody is singing live for example Kurt Nilsen with an allways amazing voice or some weak singer.This fact just confirm my theory:)Its like a cooking.You can have a best recipe in the world with the potencial to become best meal but without fresh and delicious ingredients it will be just an average or disgusting..I dont wanna flame..I just want to learn sound design because I find it as a most important but I have no idea how or where:(
 
Last edited:
I'd say it's the combination of the sound and the melody that makes a sound great.
No sound will help if the melodic theme is poor (unless you're one of them brainwashed radiomusic worshippers).
The important thing is that it conveys the emotional message as good as possible.

Those artists have put a lot of effort in finding the most suitable sound for a melody (I once watched a deadmau5 stream when I was bored, and he spent ages to find the best sound for a fill-in melody).
Not to mention how experienced they are.

And no, I don't think they have a crew of sounddesigners, they're either just very good at creating sounds, or they have a complete arsenal of presets.
Speaking of Avicii, maybe you should take a look at the famous video of him in the studio making "Dancing In My Head"... it's only presets.
Also, what you hear is a mixed and mastered track, while those examples that you see on Youtube are far from that balanced quality.
 
Hi recently more I am focused at finding great sounds more I am experiencing how hard it actally is.I have no idea how to do it or where to get those great profesional sounding presets..There is a lot of possibilities where to buy some but honestly I am not happy with those sounds ,probably because I have no idea how to layer leads,bass or whatever..I believe that sound is more important than melodies because if you watch some youtube remakes you can hear that every great song is most of the time killed just by wrong sound design..All those "greatest" melodies sound as cheap as the actuall cheap sounds.So its possible to learn sound designing?Are all those famous producers such a good sound designers or they only do a melody and they have a team of specialist for sound designing?I like a pop songs from Avicii,Calvin Harris and I like those great, clear and simple sounds..I have no idea how to achieve similar results?I find a lot of tutorials but they sound not even close to avicii or Calvin Harris original tracks:(

You are terribly misinformed. I'd recommend put down production for awhile and go buy an acoustic instrument. Play the s**t out of those notes until you understand what ones go well together and what one's sound like garbage. THEN start producing again and MAKE some cool sounds. YOur sounds are nothing without playing the right notes(this is EXACTLY what's wrong with music production today). SUre the best producers have cool sounds, but you will NEVER emotionally captivate your audience playing the wrong notes.
 
Steffeh of course melody is also important..But even greatest melody can be killed by bad sounds..Btw you are wrong I am listening everything including Mozart,Rachmaninov,Steve Vai,Joe Satriani,Gary Moore,Dream Theater,Disturbet and also I really like Taproot and Alter Bridge..I am listening radio music too, maybe you think its cool to hate all radio music?I have seen Avicii in studio making dancing in my head and I know he was using presets but it was just a scheme.Final version sounds differently and much better..I have seen also Nicky Romero in studio and he was talking that his mastered and pre-mastered tracks soiunds the same ,only difference is that mastered track is louder.So it looks like its not a matter of mastering..I guess if there are choosen the right and quality sounds then even mixing shouldnt be so difficult..
Wapiti-you sounds like some 13 years old rude snotty kid...I was singing in a band and I am playing guitar too..
I was asking for help where can I find some good materials for learning and understanding sound design thats all.
 
Last edited:
Steffeh of course melody is also important..But even greatest melody can be killed by bad sounds..Btw you are wrong I am listening everything including Mozart,Rachmaninov,Steve Vai,Joe Satriani,Gary Moore,Dream Theater,Disturbet and also I really like Taproot and Alter Bridge..I am listening radio music too, maybe you think its cool to hate all radio music?I have seen Avicii in studio making dancing in my head and I know he was using presets but it was just a scheme.Final version sounds differently and much better..I have seen also Nicky Romero in studio and he was talking that his mastered and pre-mastered tracks soiunds the same ,only difference is that mastered track is louder.So it looks like its not a matter of mastering..I guess if there are choosen the right and quality sounds then even mixing shouldnt be so difficult..
Wapiti-you sounds like some 13 years old rude snotty kid...I was singing in a band and I am playing guitar too..
I was asking for help where can I find some good materials for learning and understanding sound design thats all.

You are listening to Mozart but you don't think melody matters? Sorry this snotty kid is done helping. Enjoy making non-musical music.
 
I get what gamblerrrr is saying, sound does matter, no one wants to hear the greatest guitar solo ever if the damned guitar is out of tune and played through a crappy amp with a crappy speaker. BUTTTTTT....sound design doesn't matter to the extent that it would take precedence over the melody, imo.
 
Steffeh of course melody is also important..But even greatest melody can be killed by bad sounds..Btw you are wrong I am listening everything including Mozart,Rachmaninov,Steve Vai,Joe Satriani,Gary Moore,Dream Theater,Disturbet and also I really like Taproot and Alter Bridge..I am listening radio music too, maybe you think its cool to hate all radio music?I have seen Avicii in studio making dancing in my head and I know he was using presets but it was just a scheme.Final version sounds differently and much better..I have seen also Nicky Romero in studio and he was talking that his mastered and pre-mastered tracks soiunds the same ,only difference is that mastered track is louder.So it looks like its not a matter of mastering..I guess if there are choosen the right and quality sounds then even mixing shouldnt be so difficult..
Wapiti-you sounds like some 13 years old rude snotty kid...I was singing in a band and I am playing guitar too..
I was asking for help where can I find some good materials for learning and understanding sound design thats all.

And even the greatest sound can be killed by an improper or poor melody.
They need both to cooperate.

No hating on the radio intended, and I don't think it's cool to hate it, but I am pretty disappointed on todays radio world (especially when I hear how it used to be back in the days). And I'm also disappointed on people who only follow the radio (hence the "brainwashed radio worshippers"), and doesn't go on their own journey to find music.

As for the Avicii-thing, I'm sure he really tried to produce the song in the video with FM Mag, but was later on once again unhappy with the track and changed a lot of of the sounds. If he then switched presets and/or made some new sounds from scratch is something we'll never know I guess.

To be honest, if the only difference between a mix and a master is the loudness, then it's not a good master... I bet there were a lot more going on than just increasing the loudness (both processing-wise and thought-wise).

It's true what you're saying, good sound selection can mean easier mixing, but I personally would rather focus on getting an as interesting piece of music before mixing, than writing it so the mix will work as good as possible (though there are many different opinions about this).
My state of mind is that mixing will fix any additional issues from sound selection anyway.
But what I refered to, was that mixing shapes a lot of things in the sounds, and that can have a drastic effect.
Some tutorials may actually have successfully recreated a sound, but they don't mix them, so it still doesn't sound the same.
I've watched a tutorial where they successfully recreated a Porter Robinson patch, and boy half of the tutorial was the mixing part.
But yeah, there are a lot of tutorials in music production where they don't have a clue of what they're doing.

Anyway if you want to learn sounddesign:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MzN89Rc_06M
Synth Secrets: Links to All Parts (the first article is far down, and it all goes up, so you don't get confused).
While reading, experiment with those knobs you've read about, and learn to recognize how they affect the sound.

P.S: In the future, remember that the title of the thread give others the impression of what you want to know, if you'd named this thread something like "Sounddesign help", I'm sure the focus of the thread would been a lot more about different sounddesign series and such. :)
 
I think:

Melody is always more important,
BUT
in pop and music where the melodies are very simple, writing melodies is probably easier than making good sounds, (it will depend on experience though) so what's lacking can often be the sound design.
 
Last edited:
Hi recently more I am focused at finding great sounds more I am experiencing how hard it actally is.I have no idea how to do it or where to get those great profesional sounding presets..There is a lot of possibilities where to buy some but honestly I am not happy with those sounds ,probably because I have no idea how to layer leads,bass or whatever..I believe that sound is more important than melodies because if you watch some youtube remakes you can hear that every great song is most of the time killed just by wrong sound design..All those "greatest" melodies sound as cheap as the actuall cheap sounds.So its possible to learn sound designing?Are all those famous producers such a good sound designers or they only do a melody and they have a team of specialist for sound designing?I like a pop songs from Avicii,Calvin Harris and I like those great, clear and simple sounds..I have no idea how to achieve similar results?I find a lot of tutorials but they sound not even close to avicii or Calvin Harris original tracks:(

Focus on music composition first. Construct the bass, harmony, melody, rhythm and structure. Worry about the instrumentation/sound design after you know that the music itself is actually good.

This is my perspective at least. Unless you want to be one of those artists who's music consists of little musical material and just a bunch of sounds.

I'm not saying that sound design isn't important. The sounds/instrumentation that you decide to fill in the notes will determine the timbre/mood/vibe of the song. Just try not to make it your first priority.
 
Last edited:
Thank you Steffeeh a lot for those materials!I know name of the threat is not a best one:)Danny actually I dont like bunch of sounds..I like electronic music with a few instruments and tracks with an "acoustical feel"..I want to achieve sounds like in the unplugged songs..Sorry I dont know how to decsribe it better because of my terrible english..I like just a bass,some piano chords and one top lead melody with an interesting rich sound..Also at this moment what I struggle with is a mixing piano and lead melody.Because they play most of the time same frequencies..So I need to learn how to make space for those two instruments in mix..I find that if piano is without and lead with a little sidechain then it sounds better little bit..But it still dont sound the way I want..Also I was trying to recreate first 30 second of this Avicii song https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpKyzSxVhk4 because it sounds the way I like it but I am not able to do that.Its sounds terrible if you listen to it https://soundcloud.com/gamblerrrr/fff ..I found some remakes of this but dont sounds good too:(
 
Last edited:
Back
Top