Do you program or play the drums?

Taboosun

Taboosun

New member
Hi guys. This questioned just popped up not too long ago and I was curious to see the responses. The reason i ask is because just yesterday when I was making a beat I played my drums via the keys instead of programming and i must say, I loved it. It was a little sloppy the first couple times but that is expected, since i always program my drums.
 
Oh, and by play, I mean play an actual kit with sticks in hand and feet on teh pedals.....
 
Sometimes I play the kick and clap/snare on my m-audio keystation, I also used my roland drum machine a few times never liked it much though. But on hi hats I usually program them lol hi hats are hard to play for me... Never played a real drum set though.
 
if you are drummer, you can easily program drums with your mouse ;)
if not, good luck
it depends of genre you want to program...
 
I think that it's better to play them.Even if you decide to quantize them after,you still get more creative by playing them instead of just clicking the mouse.
 
zex said:
how he can be creative when he plays on keybord? :P
Click to expand...
How can he be creative when he fills some boxes with a mouse click ? When you make a melody do you agree with me that you have to play the keyboard for best results ? Well....in my opinion,it's the same with drums.A mpc/mpd is better but once you get used to playing drums on the keys it's the same thing.
 
Personally, ive been using fl studio step sequencer to program my drums. I recently experimented with the FPC plugin in fl studio for my drums. I recorded everything live one by one (kick, snare, hi hat, cymbals, open hi hat, percussion , and etc). In the beginning it was hard to get it too go smooth, but i kept practising till it sounded just right for me.

I believe that the drums sound way to robotic when you program them. You want your music to have a human touch as much as possible, it makes a big difference to record everything live as much as possible, instead of just clicking it in piano roll, and etc.
 
Last edited:
I'm too perfectionistic to not program my drums.
I program all my drums with the FPC inside the Piano Roll.
I want every Snare on 2th and 4th beat to be at Velocity 78 (standard velocity FL Studio). And i don't want different releases and everything.
And even though i just program my drums they still sound more human than any Trap beat you hear.
I always sequence my drums at 2 different velocities between every 1 step (78 velocity), 2 step (48 velocity), 3 step (78 velocity), 4 step (48 velocity) etc... which makes it sound more human.

check it, i made and processed the drumsounds myself from a drumbreak (velocity 78, velocity 48):

Smile by Mark-1988 on SoundCloud - Create, record and share your sounds for free

---------- Post added at 09:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:27 PM ----------
zex said:
it isn't same...
drumming is math... and feeling!
melody is something else...
Click to expand...

melody is math and feeling to but you only use 1 sound in different pitch-tones.
While with drums you use different sounds all in 1 pitch-tone.
 
Last edited:
I think that playing your drums gives you more creativity and freedom. When you program them, it is very hard to express what you are looking for.
 
I play them on my Akai MPD16 most of the time. If there is a little part I'm not satisfied with, I just program it.
 
I program them, then use velocity and shift options in FL to give it a little swing, I find it faster for me this way. If I had the option I would just have a drummer come in and play.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top